Punxsutawney Phil may be the best-known weather-predicting groundhog, but a new list is throwing shade on how much his predictions should be trusted — while New York City's rodent prognosticator is tops in the country.
Phil -- who with the help of handlers bases his prediction on if he sees his shadow -- came in 17th out of 19 critters ranked by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's National Centers for Environmental Information's grading the groundhogs list.
In fact, Phil did so poorly that taxidermized critters were found to be better at forecasting an early spring. The only alive animal the Pennsylvania icon beat out was Mojave Max, a tortoise from Nevada with a 25% accuracy rate.
Watch NBC 4 free wherever you are
WATCH HEREMeanwhile, Staten Island Chuck got rave reviews from NOAA.
Which 'groundhogs' are best at Feb. 2 predictions of more winter?
Get Tri-state area news delivered to your inbox with NBC New York's News Headlines newsletter.
SIGN UP Chuck, also known as Charles G. Hogg, topped NOAA's list with an 85% accuracy rate. While he may be the most reliable weather predictor, his behavior is notably less so: Chuck once bit then-Mayor Michael Bloomberg. Then, of course, there was the infamous incident with Mayor Bill de Blasio.
Georgia's General Beauregard Lee was second at 80% and Wyoming's Lander Lil (which isn't even a living animal) in third at 75%. Punxsutawney Phil came in at 17th out of 19 -- behind a trio of taxidermied groundhogs -- with an accuracy rate of just 35%, NOAA said.
"Although he is not the most accurate seasonal prognosticator, we would be remiss not to honor the longest-running weather-forecasting groundhog in the United States, Punxsutawney Phil," NOAA wrote. "A beloved national celebrity, legend has it that he has been prophesying when spring would arrive from his burrow on Gobler’s Knob since 1887. How has he lived for so long? The answer is simple… the “groundhog nog” fed to him each fall at Punxsutawney’s annual Groundhog Picnic."
How do critters qualify for NOAA's weather-predicting 'groundhogs' list?
The list compiled of February 2 weather-predicting critters had some criteria, according to NOAA:
- They must have been prognosticating for at least 20 years.
- They must be active prognosticators as of February 2, 2024.
"These groundhogs — along with a tortoise, whose emergence from his winter brumation (hibernation for reptiles) foretells the coming of Spring, and a Prairie dog statue, whose shadow at sunrise predicts how long it will be until Spring arrives — have been graded and ranked based on their accuracy over the past 20 years, using the March temperature averages for the U.S. each year from 2005 to 2024," NOAA noted.
Will Phil be right in 2025?
Tune in early on Sunday, Feb. 2, 2025, to see if Phil sees his shadow this year, meaning six more weeks of winter.
