Long Island Catholic Diocese Challenges NY's Child Victims Act
The Child Victim Act, passed earlier this year, extended the state's statute of limitations for onetime victims of child sexual abuse to file criminal charges or civil lawsuits
•
Victims have one year to file lawsuits that were previously not under the statute of limitations. The Boy Scouts of America, Roman Catholic Church, schools, hospitals and Jeffrey Epstein were just some of the targets named in the lawsuits. NBC 4 New York’s Rana Novini reports.
What to Know
Catholic officials on Long Island have filed a legal challenge arguing the Child Victims Act violates the New York state constitution
The Roman Catholic Diocese of Rockville said in a court filing Tuesday that a provision of the law enacted this year violates the due proces
The Child Victims Act that loosened statutes of limitations on molestation cases, and created a one-year litigation window
Catholic officials on Long Island have filed a legal challenge arguing that the Child Victims Act that loosened statutes of limitations on molestation cases violates the New York state constitution.
The Roman Catholic Diocese of Rockville said in a court filing Tuesday that a provision of the law enacted this year violates the due process clause of the state constitution.
"A basic tenet of every legal system, including New York's, is that statutes of limitations protect a fundamental right of repose that benefits both potential defendants and society at large by ensuring that individual rights are protected and the courts can function properly," the motion filed in Nassau County state Supreme Court says.
Martin Meissner/AP
Photos of parishioners, who were asked to send in pictures to represent them, are placed on empty seats due to the coronavirus at the Evangelical St. Pankratius church on Easter Monday, April 13, 2020, in Hamm, Germany. Believers in Germany still can not celebrate services at the closed churches, mosques and synagogues because of the virus outbreak.
Steven Senne/AP
Rev. William Schipper, pastor of Mary, Queen of the Rosary Parish, left, wears a mask and gloves out of concern for the coronavirus as he sprinkles holy water and blesses parishioners who remain in their vehicles in the parking lot of the church, on Easter Sunday, April 12, 2020, in Spencer, Massachusetts. Churches needed to get creative in an age of social distancing for Easter, going as far as to host drive-through masses and streaming services on the web.
Sean Rayford/Getty Images
Sylvia Salley looks at the remains of her sister’s storm-damaged home April 13, 2020, in Livingston, South Carolina. A string of storms caused more than a dozen deaths across the southern United States.
Alex Davidson/Getty Images
The Wimbledon brand as seen at The All England Tennis and Croquet Club, April 1, 2020, in London, England. Wimbledon was cancelled for the first time since World War II on Wednesday, as countries around the world grapple with outbreaks of COVID-19 cases at home and abroad. Wimbledon was scheduled to play June 29 to July 12.
Spencer Platt/Getty Images
Members of Samaritans’s Purse put the finishing touches on a field hospital in New York’s Central Park on March 30, 2020, in New York City. The group plans to open a 68-bed field hospital specifically equipped to serve as a respiratory care unit as New York grapples with tens of thousands of COVID-19 cases.
Bryan R. Smith/AFP via Getty Images
The USNS Comfort medical ship moves up the Hudson River past the Statue of Liberty as it arrives on March 30, 2020, in New York. The military hospital ship arrived Monday as America’s coronavirus epicenter prepares to fight the peak of the pandemic that has killed over 2,500 people across the US. It will treat non-virus-related patients, helping to ease the burden of hospitals overwhelmed by the crisis.
Domenico Stinellis, Antonio Calanni, Luca Bruno/AP
Italian doctors and nurses pose for portraits during a break or at the end of their shifts in Rome, Bergamo and Brescia, Italy, March 27, 2020. The intensive care doctors and nurses on the front lines of the coronavirus pandemic in Italy are often almost unrecognizable behind their masks, scrubs, gloves and hairnets.
Tomas Stargardter/AP
A forest fire burns on a hill north of Mexico City, Saturday, March 28, 2020–one of several to burn in the hills surrounding Mexico City for the past two days.
Jeff Chiu/AP
A man looks toward the skyline from Bernal Heights Hill in San Francisco, March 16, 2020. Officials in six San Francisco Bay Area counties issued a shelter-in-place mandate Monday affecting nearly 7 million people, including the city of San Francisco itself. The order says residents must stay inside and venture out only for necessities for three weeks starting Tuesday in a desperate attempt by officials to curb the spread of the novel coronavirus.
Craig Ruttle/AP
Trader Gregory Rowe, center, and others work on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange Monday, March 16, 2020. Monday’s close saw the worst loss for Wall Street in 30 years over fears of the coronavirus outbreak grinding economies to a halt.
Ted S. Warren/AP
Neal Browning receives a shot in the first-stage safety study clinical trial of a potential vaccine for COVID-19, the disease caused by the new coronavirus, March 16, 2020, at the Kaiser Permanente Washington Health Research Institute in Seattle. Browning is the second patient to receive the shot in the study.
Aaron Favila/AP
A police officer checks temperatures as part of precautionary measures against the spread of the new coronavirus in Manila, Philippines, March 16, 2020. For most people, the new coronavirus causes only mild or moderate symptoms. For some, it can cause more severe illness, especially in older adults and people with existing health problems.
Lin Shanchuan/Xinhua via AP
Rescuers search for victims at the site of a hotel collapse in Quanzhou, China, March 8, 2020. The death toll rose to 20 on Tuesday after the collapse of the Chinese hotel that was being used to isolate people who had arrived from other parts of China hit hard by the coronavirus outbreak. Ten people are still missing.
Getty Images
Medical professionals pose for photos as the last batch of COVID-19 patients are discharged from the Wuchang Fang Cang makeshift hospital, March 10, 2020, in Wuhan, China. The city has closed 11 temporary hospitals as the number of patients dropped.
Noah Berger/AP
The Grand Princess is held off the coast of San Francisco, March 8, 2020. The city is prepared to receive the thousands of people aboard the ship, 21 of whom tested positive for the coronavirus, on Monday.
Antonio Calann/AP
Inmates stage a protest on the roof of the San Vittore prison in Milan against new rules made to cope with the coronavirus crisis, including the suspension of relatives’ visits, March 9, 2020. Italy took a page from China’s playbook Sunday, attempting to lock down 16 million people — more than a quarter of its population — for nearly a month to halt the relentless march of the new coronavirus across Europe.
Rebecca Blackwell/AP
A police officer stands behind her riot shield covered in red paint during an International Women’s Day march in Mexico City’s main square, the Zocalo, Sunday, March 8, 2020. Protests against gender violence in Mexico have intensified in recent years amid an increase in killings of women and girls.
Marcio Jose Sanchez/AP
Democratic presidential candidate former Vice President Joe Biden, right, and his wife Jill attend a primary election night rally Tuesday, March 3, 2020, in Los Angeles. Biden won 9 states on Super Tuesday with one race still too close to call.
Wade Payne/AP
Two men look at damage Tuesday, March 3, 2020, in Cookeville, Tenn. after a tornado hit on Monday night.
Joe Raedle/Getty Images
From left: former Mayor of South Bend Pete Buttigieg, Rev. Al Sharpton, Sen. Amy Klobuchar and Democratic presidential candidate Sen. Elizabeth Warren walk together over the Edmund Pettus Bridge on March 1, 2020, in Selma, Alabama. Some of the 2020 Democratic presidential candidates attended a Selma bridge crossing jubilee ahead of Super Tuesday.
Elaine Thompson/AP
A person is taken by a stretcher to a waiting ambulance from a nursing facility where more than 50 people are sick and being tested for the COVID-19 virus, Saturday, Feb. 29, 2020, in Kirkland, Washington. Two patients stricken with the coronavirus died in Washington state, health officials said.
Aaron Favila/AP
Hostages walk out at the V-Mall in Manila, Philippines, March 2, 2020, after a day-long hostage crisis. Officials say a recently dismissed security guard entered the mall with a pistol and grenades and took dozens of mall employees hostage. The suspect, identified as Archie Paray, was allowed to speak to the media before he was arrested.
Morry Gash/AP
Police respond to reports of an active shooting at the Molson Coors Brewing Co. campus in Milwaukee, Wednesday, Feb. 26, 2020. Five people died when a 51-year-old former employee opened fire at the plant before killing himself, authorities said.
Nariman El-Mofty/AP
Supporters of ousted President Hosni Mubarak hold posters with his photograph near the cemetery where he will be buried, in the Heliopolis neighborhood of Cairo, Egypt, Wednesday, Feb. 26, 2020. Egypt held a full-honors military funeral for Mubarak, who was ousted from power in the 2011 Arab Spring uprising. Mubarak, 91, died Tuesday at a Cairo military hospital from heart and kidney complications.
Dennis Fujimoto/The Garden Island via AP
Lori Vallow appears in court in Lihue, Hawaii, Feb. 26, 2020. A judge ruled that bail will remain at $5 million for Vallow, also known as Lori Daybell, who was arrested in Hawaii over the disappearance of her two children in Idaho.
Andreas Solaro/AFP via Getty Images
Women wearing a respiratory mask walks across Piazza del Duomo in central Milan, Feb. 23, 2020. Tens of thousands of Italians prepared for a weeks-long quarantine in the country’s north as 219 people tested positive for coronavirus, making Italy the site of the highest number of cases outside Asia.
Ina Fassbender/AFP via Getty Images
Carnival revellers crowd at the roadside and watch a float depicting the “carnival virus” making a fool of the coronavirus during the Rose Monday carnival street parade in Duesseldorf, Germany, Feb. 24, 2020.
Alex Brandon/AP
President Donald Trump, with first lady Melania Trump, tour the Taj Mahal, Monday, Feb. 24, 2020, in Agra, India. This is the first official visit to India for the Trumps. See more photos here.
Jae C. Hong/AP
Members of the press surrounds an unidentified passenger after he disembarked from the Diamond Princess cruise ship, Feb. 19, 2020, in Yokohama, Japan. Passengers that tested negative for COVID-19 were allowed to disembark Wednesday after a 14-day quarantine.
Ng Han Guan/AP
Chinese e-commerce giant JD.com delivery workers prepare for the morning round of deliveries from a distribution center in Beijing, China, Feb. 18, 2020. JD and rivals including Pinduoduo, Miss Fresh and Alibaba Group’s Hema are scrambling to fill a boom in orders while protecting employees. E-commerce is one of the few industries to thrive after anti-virus controls starting in late January closed factories, restaurants, cinemas, offices and shops nationwide and extinguished auto and real estate sales.
Jennifer Freeman, an attorney who represents plaintiffs who say they were sexually abused as children, says the diocese is "moving to shield predators" and "hide the heinous crimes that occurred under their watch."
"With this motion, the Diocese of Rockville and officials within the Catholic Church are demonstrating their cowardice, hypocrisy, and refusal to do what is right," Freeman said.
The Child Victim Act, passed earlier this year, extended the state's statute of limitations for onetime victims of child sexual abuse to file criminal charges or civil lawsuits. The law also created the one-year litigation window, which lawmakers said was needed because before the change this year New York had one of the nation's tightest statutes of limitations. More than 400 cases were filed on the first day of the litigation window in August against defendants including religious institutions, public and private schools and the Boy Scouts of America.
Freeman said the Rockville Centre diocese's motion is apparently the first to directly challenge the constitutionality of the law.
"When they are proven to be wrong it will confirm the propriety of all these cases," she said. "We're not scared by this."
The diocese's motion challenges the one-year window to file lawsuits over allegations of past abuse. Sean Dolan, a spokesman for the diocese, said Thursday that the diocese "is asking the court to rule on the legislature's authority to revive formerly time-barred claims."
Dolan said the diocese "will continue to respect all orders of the courts as they decide this motion and as they interpret and apply the laws of this state."
The Rockville Centre diocese has taken a harder line on the issue of abusive clergy members than many other Catholic dioceses around the country. The diocese has so far declined to release a list of priests who have been credibly accused of sexual abuse. Dozens of dioceses including the Manhattan-based Archdiocese of New York have released lists of accused priests.
About 80 lawsuits have so far been filed against the Rockville Centre diocese under the Child Victims Act.
